Article
Disadvantages of Antenuptial Contract With Accrual Explained
August 23, 2026
On this page
- How the Accrual Regime Works, The Mechanics That Drive the Disadvantages
- The Main Disadvantages, At a Glance
- The Disclosure Obligation (Section 6 of the MPA), The Risk Most Couples Underestimate
- Valuation and Tracing, The Practical Cost When the Marriage Ends
- The Accrual Claim on Death, Estate Planning Consequence
- Donations and What Counts Toward the Donor Spouse’s Accrual
- Business Ownership and Investment Growth
- Maintenance Is Not Replaced by Accrual
- The Post-EB v ER Redistribution Risk (2024)
- Why Couples Still Choose Accrual Anyway, The Matching Advantages
- How to Mitigate the Disadvantages When Drafting
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Antenuptial Contracts With Accrual in Gauteng: Notarial Execution, Deeds Office Registration, and the Pretoria / Johannesburg Filing Layer
- CONTACT US
- NEED TOP LEGAL SUPPORT IN SOUTH AFRICA? CONTACT OUR LAWYERS TODAY.
- CONTACT DETAILS
By Burger Huyser Attorneys Team
Updated: August 23, 2026
Reading Time: 14 min
An antenuptial contract (ANC) with the accrual system puts the marriage out of community of property under the Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984 but activates a financial-sharing mechanism: at dissolution (death or divorce) each spouse’s estate is valued at the start of the marriage and at the end, and the spouse whose estate grew less is entitled to half the difference from the other. The headline disadvantages are the section 6 obligation to disclose commencement values in the contract (and the risk that the contract is voided or set aside if disclosure is materially inadequate), the cost and friction of valuing and tracing both estates when the marriage ends, the accrual claim against the deceased estate on death (which reduces what is available for other beneficiaries), and the fact that accrual does not preclude a separate spousal-maintenance claim under section 23 of the same Act. None of these are reasons to refuse an ANC, they are reasons to draft it carefully, with realistic commencement values and clear asset-exclusion language, and to understand what the contract does and does not protect.
How the Accrual Regime Works, The Mechanics That Drive the Disadvantages
An ANC with accrual places the marriage out of community of property, so each spouse retains a separate estate throughout the marriage. The accrual system under section 4 of the Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984 then calculates each spouse’s “accrual” as the difference between the value of their estate at the date of the marriage (the “commencement value”) and its value at the date of dissolution, whether by divorce or death.
The spouse whose accrual is smaller claims from the spouse whose accrual is larger; the standard claim is half the difference, unless the parties stipulated a different proportion in the ANC. Certain receipts are excluded from accrual under sections 5, 6 and 7 of the Act (unless the donor or testator directed otherwise): inheritances and legacies received during the marriage, donations from a third party, damages for bodily injury or defamation, and any assets the ANC expressly excludes.
The default in South Africa for marriages on or after 1 November 1984 is marriage in community of property. Couples who do not execute an ANC before the wedding cannot retrospectively opt into the accrual system without a High Court application under section 21 of the Act, and a court will not vary the regime simply because one party has changed their mind.
The Main Disadvantages, At a Glance
| Disadvantage | What it means in practice |
|---|---|
| Section 6 disclosure obligation | Both spouses must record their starting assets in the ANC; inadequate disclosure can void the contract. |
| Accrual claim on dissolution | Spouse with smaller growth claims half the difference from the other estate on death or divorce. |
| Valuation and tracing cost | Sworn appraisers, accountants and attorneys are typically needed to calculate accrual when the marriage ends. |
| Death reduces the estate for other heirs | The accrual claim by the surviving spouse reduces what is left for children and other beneficiaries. |
| Maintenance claims still possible | Accrual does not preclude a separate section 23 maintenance claim by the financially weaker spouse. |
| Donations can reduce donor’s accrual | Donations (other than reasonable household contributions) can be set off against the donor’s accrual at dissolution. |
| Business and asset growth becomes shared | Growth in a business or investment portfolio can form part of the donor’s accrual and become claimable by the other spouse. |
| Post-EB v ER redistribution risk | A court may now order redistribution on divorce even where the parties contracted into accrual, on equity grounds. |
The Disclosure Obligation (Section 6 of the MPA), The Risk Most Couples Underestimate
Both parties must record their commencement values in the ANC, normally by annexing a balance sheet to the contract on the date of the marriage. The disclosure must cover assets owned at the date of the marriage and liabilities owed at that date; both spouses’ versions are needed for any later accrual calculation.
If a spouse misrepresents the size of their starting estate, the other spouse may apply to court to have the contract set aside or to claim damages. The test courts apply is whether the misrepresentation was so significant that the contract would not have been signed in its current form if the truth had been disclosed. Couples often treat the balance sheet as a formality rather than a sworn record; in a contested dissolution, the commencement values become the single most fought-over factual issue, and an unsigned or hastily completed annexure can be worth little when challenged.
Valuation and Tracing, The Practical Cost When the Marriage Ends
Accrual disputes routinely turn on valuation methodology rather than on whether accrual is owed. The leading valuation test comes from Manelis v Manelis, the Supreme Court of Appeal rejected the “forced-sale” or “distress-sale” approach in favour of an open-market “willing-buyer, willing-seller” valuation at the dissolution date.
- Both spouses typically commission their own sworn valuator, and the dispute is either agreed between the parties or determined by a court on expert evidence.
- Tracing is required for assets that have been bought and sold, inherited, gifted, or rolled over between investments during the marriage; this often requires a forensic accountant.
- The cost of a contested accrual calculation can run into the high five figures before any settlement or trial is reached, couples should budget for this when they elect accrual.
The Accrual Claim on Death, Estate Planning Consequence
On death, the surviving spouse has an accrual claim enforceable against the deceased estate as a debt, and the claim is settled as part of the liquidation and distribution account administered by the Master of the High Court. The claim takes priority over legacies and bequests to other beneficiaries to the extent the estate is insufficient to meet both, which is the practical risk for couples with children from prior relationships or with significant testamentary plans. Where the parties have expressly excluded accrual in the ANC (or where accrual does not otherwise apply), this claim does not arise, one reason why second marriages and blended families often choose the without-accrual regime.
Donations and What Counts Toward the Donor Spouse’s Accrual
Under section 4(2) of the MPA, the value of any donation by one spouse to the other, and any donation by one spouse to a third party which is not expressly excluded in the ANC, can be set off against that spouse’s accrual at dissolution. Reasonable household contributions do not count as donations for this purpose; large gifts to children, other relatives or charities can. Donations received by a spouse from a third party during the marriage are excluded from that spouse’s accrual under section 5 of the Act, unless the donor stipulated otherwise. Couples who make significant gifts during the marriage, to children from prior relationships, to charities, or to extended family, should record this clearly in the ANC and keep documentation to support the gift trail.
Business Ownership and Investment Growth
Growth in a spouse’s business interest, share portfolio, or investment property can form part of that spouse’s accrual and become claimable by the other spouse at dissolution. Where one spouse owns a business before the marriage, the section 6 disclosure obligation applies to its commencement value; growth on that business value during the marriage is included in accrual. Many business-owning couples resolve this by excluding specific business interests from accrual in the ANC, or by holding the business through a trust structure, which carries its own legal and tax considerations and is not a substitute for an ANC. A shareholder’s agreement and the ANC need to be read together; they can otherwise produce conflicting outcomes on a sale, a divorce, or a death.
Maintenance Is Not Replaced by Accrual
The accrual system does not preclude a spousal-maintenance claim under section 23 of the Matrimonial Property Act. A spouse who was financially weaker during the marriage can still approach the court for maintenance on divorce, over and above any accrual claim. The two remedies operate independently, the accrual claim settles the difference in growth of the estates, while the maintenance claim addresses ongoing income support. For couples with very different earning power, the accrual may not be sufficient on its own to protect the financially weaker spouse, and maintenance remains on the table.
The Post-EB v ER Redistribution Risk (2024)
The Constitutional Court’s 2024 judgment in EB v ER NO and Others 2024 (2) SA 1 (CC) extended the section 7(3) of the Divorce Act 70 of 1979 redistribution remedy, in equity, to spouses married out of community without accrual on divorce. The judgment’s underlying reasoning, that the constitutional values of equity and dignity can override strict contractual terms, is being argued by practitioners as opening redistribution arguments even in marriages with accrual, where the accrual outcome is unfair.
An ANC with accrual is therefore no longer absolute protection against redistribution; it is a strong but no longer unbreachable contractual choice. Couples relying on the certainty of accrual should take the redistribution risk into account, particularly where the marriage has lasted many years and one spouse has been the primary earner. The General Laws (Family Matters) Amendment Bill has been announced by the Minister of Justice as the legislative vehicle to address the gap, but pending enactment, an accrual marriage is the more certain of the two ANC regimes, not a guaranteed firewall.
Why Couples Still Choose Accrual Anyway, The Matching Advantages
Accrual recognises the non-monetary contribution of a stay-at-home spouse or a lower-earning spouse over a long marriage. Without accrual, a financially dependent spouse exiting after a long marriage has no automatic claim against the other’s estate, the EB v ER line does not undo this; it only allows the court to redistribute on divorce. The accrual system is a legislated default and is the most common regime chosen by SA couples with no significant pre-marital asset gap. For most marrying couples without substantial pre-marital assets or complex estate plans, the protective disadvantages of accrual are outweighed by the recognition of indirect contribution.
Burger Huyser Attorneys’ family-law practice regularly walks Gauteng couples through this trade-off at the first ANC consultation, with admitted notaries on staff at Bedfordview (Natasha van Deventer, Amanda le Roux) and Pretoria (Chanté Marais) handling the notarial execution and Deeds Office lodgement.
How to Mitigate the Disadvantages When Drafting
- Record commencement values in a sworn balance sheet at the date of the marriage, not a rough estimate.
- Use clear exclusion language in the ANC for any assets the parties want kept fully outside accrual (specific investments, business interests, expected inheritances).
- Pair the ANC with a will that anticipates the accrual claim against the deceased estate, and update the will when life events change.
- Where one spouse owns a business, document its commencement value professionally and consider whether a separate trust holding is warranted.
- Take independent legal advice before signing, the notarial execution is not legal advice; both spouses should consult their own attorneys on what the contract means for them.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does an antenuptial contract with accrual mean my spouse can claim half my business on divorce?
Not automatically, but the growth in your business’s value during the marriage can form part of your accrual under section 4 of the Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984, and your spouse may claim half the difference in growth between the two estates. The claim is a money claim, not a transfer of ownership, but a large business growth can produce a very large money claim. Many couples exclude specific business interests in the ANC by express drafting, or hold the business through a trust.
What happens to my accrual claim if my spouse dies before I do?
The surviving spouse has an accrual claim enforceable against the deceased estate as a debt under section 4 of the Matrimonial Property Act, settled as part of the liquidation and distribution account. The claim is paid before legacies and bequests to other beneficiaries if the estate is insufficient to meet both, so it can materially reduce what is left for children from prior relationships or other heirs named in the will.
Can my spouse still claim maintenance from me if we have an ANC with accrual?
Yes. Accrual is a property regime and does not preclude a separate spousal-maintenance claim under section 23 of the Matrimonial Property Act. The accrual settles the difference in growth of the estates; maintenance addresses ongoing income support. A financially weaker spouse can pursue both.
Does an ANC with accrual protect me from my spouse’s creditors?
Not as strongly as an ANC without accrual. Under the without-accrual regime, each spouse’s estate is fully sealed from the other’s creditors; under the with-accrual regime, the accrual claim itself is an asset that can be attached by the claiming spouse’s creditors if the marriage ends. Business or professional creditors of one spouse generally cannot reach the other spouse’s estate, but the accrual claim can become a point of attack.
Can I include or exclude accrual after I’ve already married?
Only with a High Court application under section 21 of the Matrimonial Property Act, and only on good grounds, typically where a sound reason has arisen after the marriage that justifies the change. A court will not vary the regime simply because one party has changed their mind. Executing the ANC before the marriage is far simpler, cheaper, and the standard approach.
Does an ANC with accrual still protect me from redistribution after divorce?
It provides strong but not absolute protection. The Constitutional Court’s 2024 judgment in EB v ER extended the section 7(3) Divorce Act redistribution remedy to marriages without accrual on divorce, and the underlying reasoning is being argued by practitioners as opening redistribution arguments even in accrual marriages where the accrual outcome is unfair. An ANC with accrual remains the more certain choice, but it is no longer unbreachable.

Antenuptial Contracts With Accrual in Gauteng: Notarial Execution, Deeds Office Registration, and the Pretoria / Johannesburg Filing Layer
Antenuptial contracts in South Africa are governed by the Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984, which applies uniformly across the country’s nine provinces; the only geographic layer the regime carries is the Deeds Office where the contract must be registered after execution and the marriage-officer step before the wedding. Couples resident in the Pretoria/Tshwane area (including Centurion, Midrand and the northern Gauteng corridor) lodge their ANCs at the Pretoria Deeds Office; couples resident in the broader Johannesburg/Randburg area (including Sandton, Roodepoort, Bedfordview and Alberton) lodge theirs at the Johannesburg Deeds Office. The Deeds Office in either city is the same institution in different seats, there is no separate “Gauteng Deeds Office”, and the registration window runs for three months from the date of execution by the notary. A common confusion is treating the local Magistrate’s Court as the relevant venue: magistrates’ courts do not register ANCs and do not vary matrimonial property regimes, which is exclusively a Deeds Office and High Court function respectively.
Burger Huyser Attorneys practises from its Linden, Randburg head office and accepts instructions on ANC drafting, execution and registration through the family-law practice, with admitted notaries on staff at Bedfordview (Natasha van Deventer, Amanda le Roux) and Pretoria (Chanté Marais) handling the attestation layer and the Deeds Office lodgement. The firm is a member of the Gauteng Family Law Forum, the Pretoria Attorneys Association, and the Johannesburg Attorneys Association. The Legal Practice Council remains the authoritative source for any updates to the underlying professional-conduct rules, and the Department of Home Affairs confirms the marriage-officer-side requirements for producing the registered ANC at the wedding.
If you are weighing whether to include the accrual system in your antenuptial contract, or want a second pair of eyes on the commencement values and exclusions in a contract you have already signed, Burger Huyser Attorneys’ family-law practice can walk you through the trade-offs in plain language. The firm drafts and registers ANCs from its admitted notaries at Bedfordview and Pretoria and accepts instructions from clients across Gauteng through the head office in Linden, Randburg (49 First Avenue, 011 888 0246). The firm carries a 4.8/5 average across 250+ Google reviews (Trustindex verified “Top Rated Law Firm in South Africa”) and is a member of the Gauteng Family Law Forum, the Pretoria Attorneys Association, and the Johannesburg Attorneys Association. Antenuptial contracts fall under the firm’s Family Law practice area, and Denisha Padachey at the Sandton branch is regularly named in client reviews for ANC and antenuptial work.
General Information Disclaimer: This article explains the general legal framework and the typical disadvantages of an antenuptial contract with accrual under the Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984, the Divorce Act 70 of 1979, and the Deeds Registries Act 47 of 1937. It is general information, not legal advice for a specific marriage or estate plan, every couple’s circumstances differ, particularly around commencement values, exclusions, business interests and testamentary plans, and the parties should consult a qualified attorney and a notary public about their own situation before signing.
CONTACT US
Burger Huyser Attorneys Team
NEED TOP LEGAL SUPPORT IN SOUTH AFRICA? CONTACT OUR LAWYERS TODAY.
Contact our team of experienced law attorneys at Burger Huyser Attorneys to assist you in all matters and procedures.
CONTACT DETAILS
CONTACT US TODAY
RANDBURG OFFICE
011 888 0246 / 061 516 6878
After Hours Bail Application
069 522 7696ROODEPOORT OFFICE
011 668 0030 / 061 516 0091
After Hours Bail Application
061 516 0091SANDTON OFFICE
011 253 3080 / 064 555 3358
After Hours Bail Application
064 555 3358PRETORIA OFFICE
012 471 5700 / 064 548 4838
After Hours Bail Application
064 548 4838BEDFORDVIEW OFFICE
011 201 7190 / 061 536 3223
After Hours Bail Application
061 536 3223CENTURION OFFICE
012 644 4990 / 061 516 7117
After Hours Bail Application
069 522 7696ALBERTON OFFICE
011 439 3990 / 061 515 4699
After Hours Bail Application
061 515 4699MIDRAND OFFICE
010 022 4082 / 064 555 3358
After Hours Bail Application
077 274 1932DEBT COLLECTION OFFICE
011 446 5960 / 079 109 8470
Monday - Friday; 7:30 AM - 16:30 PM
Speak to Burger Huyser Attorneys
Bedfordview office: 011 201 7190, Monday to Friday, 7:30 AM – 4:30 PM
