Article
The Accrual System in One Minute
On this page
- What the Antenuptial Contract Has to Say
- How the Accrual Is Calculated at Divorce
- What Can Be Excluded from the Accrual Estate
- The Manelis v Manelis Post-Nuptial Exclusion
- The Seatlholo Line and Recent Judicial Discretion
- Settling Without a Court Calculation
- What Is Not Counted in the Accrual
- Where the Process Fits Inside the Divorce Itself
- Local Filing Layer: The Gauteng Divorce Court
- Frequently Asked Questions
- CONTACT US
- NEED TOP LEGAL SUPPORT IN SOUTH AFRICA? CONTACT OUR LAWYERS TODAY.
- CONTACT DETAILS
What Happens When You Divorce Out of Community of Property With Accrual?
Burger Huyser Attorneys Team
What Happens When You Divorce Out of Community of Property With Accrual?
By Burger Huyser Attorneys Team
Updated: August 23, 2026
Reading Time: 13 min
Divorcing out of community of property with accrual means each spouse keeps their own estate, but the spouse whose estate grew by more during the marriage must share half of that growth (the “accrual”) with the other spouse, unless the antenuptial contract specifically excludes the asset or the parties conclude a settlement. The accrual is calculated by subtracting the commencement value of each spouse’s estate (the value at the date of marriage) from its termination value (the value at the date of divorce), and the spouse with the smaller accrual has a claim against the spouse with the larger accrual for half the difference. The Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984 governs the regime, and the 2010 Supreme Court of Appeal judgment in Manelis v Manelis confirmed that parties can exclude assets from the accrual estate by a post-nuptial notarial contract, provided the amendment is genuine and not a simulated donation.
The accrual system is the default “sharing” rule that applies to a marriage out of community of property where the antenuptial contract (ANC) has made the accrual system applicable. Three points capture how it works:
- Each spouse retains their own separate estate, there is no merging of assets on marriage.
- The exchange at divorce is not of the estates themselves, but of the growth (the accrual) each estate experienced during the marriage.
- The spouse with the smaller accrual has a claim against the spouse with the larger accrual for half the difference.
The system is structured to recognise that both spouses typically contribute to wealth-building during the marriage, one as earner, one as homemaker, or both in different combinations. The accrual claim is a monetary claim, not a transfer of the underlying assets, and the parties are free to settle it on different terms if they agree.
Burger Huyser Attorneys’ Divorce Law team handles this work across all Gauteng branches (Linden/Randburg, Centurion, Pretoria/Menlyn, Sandton, Bedfordview, Alberton, Roodepoort, and Midrand), routing the matter through the office closest to the client.
What the Antenuptial Contract Has to Say
The ANC is the foundation of the regime. If it is silent on the accrual question, the marriage is in community of property by default, so the contract must expressly state that the accrual system applies for the parties to be married out of community of property with accrual.
| Requirement | Rule |
|---|---|
| Timing of execution | Must be signed before the marriage takes place. |
| Registration | Must be lodged at the Deeds Office within three months of execution, or it is void as against third parties. |
| Express choice | Must expressly state that the accrual system applies, silence means community of property. |
| Excluded assets | Assets specifically listed in the ANC as excluded from the accrual stay excluded for the duration of the marriage. |
| Form of later exclusion | Informal side letters or hand-written notes cannot add or remove excluded assets post-marriage. |
Common ANC exclusions include inheritances, donations received from third parties, and specific pre-marital assets the parties want to ring-fence. The exclusion must appear in the contract itself; it cannot be added informally later.
How the Accrual Is Calculated at Divorce
The calculation itself is mechanical, but the evidence-gathering around it is what drives the time and cost of the exercise. Four values are needed before the claim can be settled or determined by a court:
- Commencement value, the net value of each spouse’s estate on the date of marriage (zero for a spouse who had nothing). Supported by a sworn affidavit and the underlying documents (bank statements, asset valuations, liability schedules).
- Termination value, the net value of each spouse’s estate on the date of divorce (or the date of separation in some circumstances). Supported by a sworn balance sheet and current valuations.
- Accrual of each spouse = termination value minus commencement value.
- The accrual claim = half of (the larger accrual minus the smaller accrual).
Each party pays the claim from their own estate; the underlying assets do not change hands. Where the parties agree on the inputs, the calculation is a one-page schedule. Where they disagree, the matter proceeds to trial and the court determines the values on the pleadings and the evidence.
Worked example: Spouse A’s estate was worth R500,000 at the date of marriage and R4,000,000 at the date of divorce, accrual of R3,500,000. Spouse B’s estate was worth R1,500,000 at the date of marriage and R3,000,000 at the date of divorce, accrual of R1,500,000. The difference is R2,000,000; the accrual claim is half of that, R1,000,000, payable by Spouse A to Spouse B from Spouse A’s own estate.
What Can Be Excluded from the Accrual Estate
The “accrual estate” is the estate of the spouse at the date of divorce, less any assets that are excluded by the ANC or by operation of law. Treatment differs depending on how the asset came into the estate:
| Asset category | Treatment in the accrual calculation |
|---|---|
| Asset expressly excluded in the ANC | Excluded for the entire duration of the marriage; only the Manelis post-nuptial mechanism can add it back in. |
| Inheritance or legacy received during the marriage | Excluded by default, it is a donation by nature and does not form part of the accrual unless the recipient chose to treat it as part of the accrual. |
| Donation from a third party during the marriage | Same rule as an inheritance, excluded by default unless the recipient chose to include it. |
| Pre-marital assets | Captured by the commencement value mechanism: their value at the date of marriage is locked in, and only the growth after the marriage is counted as accrual. |
| Asset excluded by post-nuptial notarial contract (Manelis) | Excluded from the accrual estate if the amendment is genuine and not a simulated donation. |
The Manelis v Manelis Post-Nuptial Exclusion
The 2010 SCA judgment in Manelis v Manelis confirmed that spouses can, by a post-nuptial notarial contract, exclude from the accrual estate an asset that was originally part of the accrual estate. The South African Law Society and the legal profession have treated this judgment as the leading authority on the post-nuptial exclusion mechanism since it was handed down.
Three principles flow from the case:
- The amendment must be genuine, a real amendment done for legitimate reasons.
- The amendment cannot be a simulated donation dressed up as an ANC amendment.
- The court’s test is whether the amendment is a genuine prior agreement or a disguised donation: if it is a donation, it can be set aside.
In practice, Manelis is used to ring-fence assets received mid-marriage (such as a donation from a family member) that the couple want kept out of the accrual estate. The firm has handled files where the post-nuptial amendment made the difference between an accrual claim of millions and a clean break, and Anna-Mi Nel (Director & Head of Family Law) is the partner who leads this kind of structuring work for the firm.
The Seatlholo Line and Recent Judicial Discretion
More recent High Court decisions (in the Seatlholo v Seatlholo and related line) have developed a separate doctrine: in long marriages, or where strict application of the ANC would be unjust, the court has discretion to override the contract and make a different order. The De Rebus commentary from the SERP analysis describes this as a “new era for matrimonial property law,” and the doctrinal shift is real.
Two practical caveats apply:
- The discretion is at the margins, it is not a routine workaround for spouses who simply do not like what the ANC produces.
- The discretion is most often invoked in long marriages, marriages where one spouse contributed in non-financial ways that the contract did not capture, or cases where strict application would produce a manifestly unjust result.
This is a developing area of law, and practitioners who handle accrual divorces regularly should be expected to advise on whether the line of cases is relevant to a specific set of facts.
Settling Without a Court Calculation
Most accrual divorces are settled before the court ever calculates the accrual. The procedural canvas is straightforward:
- The parties exchange sworn schedules of assets and liabilities at the commencement and termination dates.
- The parties attempt to agree the values (and the values of any specific assets that the schedules treat differently).
- Where the parties disagree on a specific valuation, an independent expert is often appointed to value the asset (business interests, immovable property, trust loan accounts all generate valuation disputes).
- The parties agree on the accrual and sign a settlement agreement.
- The settlement agreement is made an order of court and has the same legal force as a court-determined accrual.
Where the parties cannot agree, the matter goes to trial and the court calculates the accrual on the pleadings and the evidence. The trial route is significantly more expensive and time-consuming, and the parties lose control over the outcome, the result is whatever the court determines on the evidence before it.
What Is Not Counted in the Accrual
Several categories of value are routinely misunderstood. The following table captures how each is treated:
| Item | Treatment in the accrual calculation |
|---|---|
| Debts at the date of marriage | Reduce the commencement value; thereafter, accrual is calculated on asset values, not debts. |
| Wear and tear / depreciation | The value at the date of divorce is the current market value, not the original value. A depreciated asset is counted at its current value. |
| Personal-use property (furniture, clothing) | Part of the estate, but valuers frequently accept nominal or agreed values for these items. |
| Trust assets | Generally not part of the donor spouse’s estate at all, and not counted in the accrual unless the trust is a sham or the donor has so dominated the trust that the assets are treated as their own. |
Where the Process Fits Inside the Divorce Itself
The accrual claim is one of several issues to be resolved in a divorce, alongside maintenance, care and contact of minor children, and the forfeiture of benefits claim. The jurisdictional split between the Regional Court and the High Court tracks the size of the accrual claim:
- Regional Court, has jurisdiction over divorce matters, but only where the accrual claim does not exceed the Regional Court’s monetary ceiling.
- High Court (Gauteng Division, Johannesburg or Pretoria seat), has jurisdiction where the accrual claim pushes the matter above the Regional Court’s monetary threshold. In practice, most accrual divorces are filed in the High Court because the accrual claim almost always exceeds the Regional Court limit.
For Gauteng-based parties, the matter is filed at the Pretoria seat for a Centurion-based party unless the parties expressly file in Johannesburg, and at the Johannesburg seat for a West Rand party. The matter is decided at the seat where it is filed.
Local Filing Layer: The Gauteng Divorce Court
South African matrimonial-property law is national, the Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984 applies the same way in Centurion, Roodepoort, Sandton, or anywhere else in the country. Where the location matters is the venue of the divorce action itself. Where the accrual claim exceeds the Regional Court’s monetary limit (which it almost always does in a working estate), the divorce is filed in the High Court, and for Gauteng-based parties that is the Gauteng Division of the High Court, which sits in both Johannesburg and Pretoria.
Burger Huyser Attorneys handles this work as part of its dedicated Divorce Law practice, with the matter routed through the office closest to the client. The firm has qualified mediators on staff for couples who want to settle the accrual by mediation rather than by litigation, and the Divorce Law team works in coordination with the Family Law team on matters that touch on custody, maintenance, or the forfeiture of benefits.

Frequently Asked Questions
What is the accrual claim at divorce?
The accrual claim is the spouse’s right to share in half of the growth of the other spouse’s estate during the marriage. Each spouse’s estate is valued at the date of marriage and again at the date of divorce; the difference is the accrual. The spouse with the smaller accrual can claim half of the difference between the two accruals.
How is the commencement value of an estate worked out?
The commencement value is the net value of the spouse’s estate on the date of marriage. It is normally supported by a sworn affidavit that lists every asset and liability on the marriage date, with supporting documents. A spouse who had nothing on the marriage date has a commencement value of zero.
How is the termination value of an estate worked out?
The termination value is the net value of the spouse’s estate at the date of divorce (or the date of separation, in some circumstances). It is supported by a sworn balance sheet that lists every asset and liability at that date, with supporting valuations. Disagreements over valuation are typically resolved by a court-appointed expert.
Can inheritances received during the marriage be excluded from the accrual?
Yes, inheritances and legacies are donations by nature and do not form part of the accrual estate unless the recipient chose to include them. The recipient does not need to do anything special to exclude them; they are excluded by default.
What does the Manelis case actually allow?
The 2010 SCA judgment in Manelis v Manelis confirmed that spouses can, by a post-nuptial notarial contract, exclude from the accrual estate an asset that was originally part of the accrual estate. The amendment must be a genuine amendment, not a simulated donation intended to defeat a creditor or the other spouse’s claim.
Can a court override the antenuptial contract?
In recent years, the High Court has developed a limited discretion to override the ANC in long marriages or where strict application would be unjust, the Seatlholo v Seatlholo line of decisions. This is a developing area of law and applies at the margins, not as a routine workaround.
Do you have to go to court to settle the accrual?
No, most accrual divorces are settled out of court and the settlement is made an order of court. If the parties cannot agree on values or the accrual claim, the matter goes to trial and the court calculates the accrual.
Does the accrual claim include the family home?
If the family home is in the higher-accrual spouse’s name and was purchased during the marriage, its growth during the marriage will be part of that spouse’s accrual, and half of the difference between the two accruals is then claimable. The home itself does not change hands; the claim is for a monetary payment.
If you are divorcing out of community of property with accrual, or trying to work out what the accrual claim will look like before issuing, Burger Huyser Attorneys’ Divorce Law team can guide you through the calculation, the exclusions, and the settlement from the first consultation. Initial consultations are booked at the office closest to you; the firm fields this work across all Gauteng branches (Linden/Randburg head office 011 888 0246, Centurion 012 644 4990, Pretoria/Menlyn 012 471 5700, Sandton 011 253 3080, Bedfordview 011 201 7190, Alberton 011 439 3990, Roodepoort 011 668 0030, Midrand 010 022 4082). The firm carries a 4.8/5 average across 250+ Google reviews (Trustindex verified “Top Rated Law Firm in South Africa”) and has qualified mediators on staff for couples who want to settle the accrual by mediation rather than by litigation.
General Information Disclaimer: This article describes the general legal framework for divorce out of community of property with accrual under the Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984. It is general information, not legal advice for a specific case. Every divorce involves its own facts around valuation, exclusions, and settlement, and parties should consult a qualified attorney about their own situation before agreeing to any accrual figure or settlement. Confirm current procedural requirements with the Legal Practice Council and the relevant division of the High Court.
CONTACT US
NEED TOP LEGAL SUPPORT IN SOUTH AFRICA? CONTACT OUR LAWYERS TODAY.
Contact our team of experienced law attorneys at Burger Huyser Attorneys to assist you in all matters and procedures.
CONTACT DETAILS
CONTACT US TODAY
RANDBURG OFFICE
011 888 0246 / 061 516 6878
After Hours Bail Application
069 522 7696ROODEPOORT OFFICE
011 668 0030 / 061 516 0091
After Hours Bail Application
061 516 0091SANDTON OFFICE
011 253 3080 / 064 555 3358
After Hours Bail Application
064 555 3358PRETORIA OFFICE
012 471 5700 / 064 548 4838
After Hours Bail Application
064 548 4838BEDFORDVIEW OFFICE
011 201 7190 / 061 536 3223
After Hours Bail Application
061 536 3223CENTURION OFFICE
012 644 4990 / 061 516 7117
After Hours Bail Application
069 522 7696ALBERTON OFFICE
011 439 3990 / 061 515 4699
After Hours Bail Application
061 515 4699MIDRAND OFFICE
010 022 4082 / 064 555 3358
After Hours Bail Application
077 274 1932DEBT COLLECTION OFFICE
011 446 5960 / 079 109 8470
Monday - Friday; 7:30 AM - 16:30 PM
Speak to Burger Huyser Attorneys
Bedfordview office: 011 201 7190, Monday to Friday, 7:30 AM – 4:30 PM
