Skip to main content
Burger Huyser Attorneys Bedfordview, Johannesburg Family Law Criminal & Commercial Law Litigation Wills & Estates

Article

What a Shareholders’ Agreement Is (and What It Is Not)

On this page

Why You Need a Shareholders Agreement for Private Limited Company?
Burger Huyser Attorneys Team

Why You Need a Shareholders Agreement for Private Limited Company?

By Burger Huyser Attorneys Team
Updated: August 23, 2026

Reading Time: 8 min

A shareholders’ agreement is a private contract between the shareholders of a private company that supplements the company’s Memorandum of Incorporation (MOI) and the default rules of the Companies Act 71 of 2008, letting the shareholders set their own rules on share transfers, decision-making, deadlock resolution, dividend policy, and exit, which the Act’s default rules do not adequately cover for closely-held companies. Without one, shareholders fall back on the Act’s default position, which favours majority control and gives minority shareholders limited protection, leading to deadlocked decisions, no forced-buyout mechanism when a shareholder wants to leave, no restrictions on shares passing to a competitor, and disputes that end up in costly High Court litigation. The agreement matters most where two or more shareholders hold unequal stakes, where family members are co-shareholders, or where external investors are involved.

Talk with Burger Huyser Attorneys

Section 15 of the Companies Act 71 of 2008 expressly recognises shareholders’ agreements. Four points are settled:

  • It is a private contract between shareholders, additional to the company’s Memorandum of Incorporation.
  • It does not replace the MOI; the MOI is the constitutive document filed with the Companies and Intellectual Property Commission and is publicly accessible, while the agreement is private between the parties.
  • It is not legally compulsory, but the Act’s default rules are not designed for the closely-held company.
  • It binds only the shareholders who sign it; new shareholders sign a deed of accession.

Why You Need One: The Gaps the Companies Act Leaves

The Companies Act is built on the assumptions that the company is widely held or has a clear majority and that disputes are rare. For a closely-held company those assumptions fail, and the Act’s defaults leave five gaps that recur in practice.

Default majority control

Ordinary resolutions pass on a simple majority and special resolutions on 75%. Beyond the statutory remedies in sections 163 (derivative action) and 164 (appraisal rights), a 51% holder can outvote a 49% holder on most operational decisions.

No automatic deadlock mechanism

Where two equal shareholders or an evenly-split board cannot agree, the Act gives no default tie-breaker, the company grinds to a halt.

No restriction on share transfers by default

Without a restriction in the MOI or agreement, shares can pass to a competitor, an ex-spouse, a creditor in insolvency, or anyone else the other shareholders would not have chosen as a partner.

No default exit mechanism

The Act gives no shareholder a right to force a buyout and supplies no valuation formula. Disagreements over price drag on for years; the parties end up in High Court litigation.

No default rules on reserved matters

Decisions like admitting new shareholders, taking on debt above a threshold, or selling a major asset can be made by ordinary board majority unless carved out as reserved matters requiring higher approval.

Burger Huyser Attorneys’ commercial law practice, led by specialist consultant J’Retha van Rensburg, drafts shareholders’ agreements that close these gaps as a single integrated document.

What a Shareholders’ Agreement Typically Covers

A workable agreement for a South African private company usually covers the seven heads below.

What a Shareholders’ Agreement Typically Covers
ClauseWhat it does
Share transfer restrictionsPre-emption rights, ROFR / ROFO structures, lock-in periods, and rules for shares on death, divorce, or insolvency.
Tag-along and drag-along rightsTag-along lets minority join a sale on the same terms; drag-along lets majority force minority to join, keeping all shareholders on the same exit timeline.
Decision-making thresholdsReserved matters (budget, new debt above a threshold, key appointments, disposals above a value) requiring approval beyond ordinary majority.
Deadlock resolutionStep-by-step escalation: negotiation, mediation, then a defined exit mechanism, commonly a “Texas shoot-out” buy-sell or arbitration.
Dividend policyWhat must be distributed, what can be retained, how policy is set and varied, and any minimum-dividend obligations linked to share classes.
Confidentiality and non-competeRestricts shareholders from competing during the shareholding and for a defined period after exit.
Exit mechanismsTriggers (death, disability, insolvency, divorce, voluntary exit); valuation method, payment terms, who buys the shares.

When to Put a Shareholders’ Agreement in Place

The cheapest moment is at incorporation; the document is then revisited whenever the shareholder base shifts.

  1. At incorporation. Everyone signs the MOI at the same time, so the agreement can be raised alongside it.
  2. When a new shareholder is admitted. Every new shareholder should sign a deed of accession to the existing agreement, not a side-letter that overrides it.
  3. When circumstances change. A new investor, a family member joining, or a brewing dispute all justify revisiting the document, well before any becomes a court matter.

Once a dispute has started, the cost of negotiating an agreement rises sharply, and the conversation becomes adversarial rather than collaborative.

Common Situations Where Not Having One Causes Real Problems

The five situations below are recurring patterns the firm sees in shareholder disputes at the Linden/Randburg head office.

Common Situations Where Not Having One Causes Real Problems
SituationWhat goes wrong without an agreement
Two-shareholder deadlock50/50 split, no tie-breaker, no exit; the company grinds to a halt and dividends are suspended.
Minority squeeze-outMajority excludes minority from information, decisions, or dividends; statutory remedies are narrow and slow.
Co-founder exitWithout an agreed valuation method, the remaining shareholders and the exiting one fight for years over the price.
Death or insolvencyShares pass to an estate or trustee the other shareholders do not want, who then holds full rights.
Third-party sale to a competitorNo contractual restriction means no ability to block a sale to someone objectionable.

Where shareholder disputes get decided

Shareholder disputes are company-law matters heard in the Gauteng Division of the High Court (Johannesburg or Pretoria), the Magistrate’s Court has no jurisdiction. Less adversarial matters can go to the Companies Tribunal, an independent body under the Companies Act that offers a faster first stop than litigation. Burger Huyser Attorneys handles both drafting and follow-on disputes across its Gauteng branches, with the head office at 49 First Avenue, Linden, Randburg (011 888 0246) as the intake point.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a shareholders’ agreement legally required in South Africa?

No, the Companies Act 71 of 2008 does not require one for a private company. It is, however, strongly recommended for any company with more than one shareholder, because the Act’s default rules favour majority control and do not adequately cover typical closely-held situations (transfer restrictions, deadlock, exit, minority protection).

What is the difference between a shareholders’ agreement and the company’s Memorandum of Incorporation (MOI)?

The MOI is the company’s constitutive document, filed with the CIPC and publicly accessible; it binds the company, its directors, and its shareholders on matters the Act requires to be in the MOI. The shareholders’ agreement is a private contract between the shareholders only, it does not bind the company directly unless the company also signs it, and it can be more detailed than the MOI on matters the Act does not require to be in the MOI. The MOI is the public document; the agreement is the detailed private one.

Can a shareholders’ agreement cover what the Companies Act already covers?

Yes, the agreement can reproduce, vary, or supplement the Act’s default rules. Where the agreement is inconsistent with the MOI on a matter the Act allows the MOI to cover, the MOI typically prevails as between the company and shareholders; the agreement is binding on the shareholders as a contract between them.

How much does it cost to have a shareholders’ agreement drafted?

Fees depend on the number of shareholders, the size of the company, whether the agreement includes tax, valuation, and dispute-resolution mechanisms, and how much negotiation is required. A straightforward two-shareholder agreement is materially cheaper than a multi-shareholder agreement with preferred-investor protections. Burger Huyser Attorneys quotes per file after the first consultation.

What happens if there is no shareholders’ agreement and a shareholder wants to leave?

The default position is that the shareholder owns their shares indefinitely and can only exit by selling on terms they negotiate with the other shareholders or a third party. If the others do not want to buy and there is no pre-emptive rights mechanism, the shareholder may be stuck, and if they sell to a third party, the remaining shareholders have no contractual right to block the transfer.

Do all shareholders have to sign the agreement?

Yes, every shareholder on the date the agreement is signed must be a party. New shareholders added later sign a deed of accession to be bound by the same terms; a shareholder who is not a party has no contractual obligations under it.

If you are setting up a private company, taking on a co-shareholder, or finding that the current shareholder arrangement is no longer working, Burger Huyser Attorneys’ commercial law and contracts practice can draft or review a shareholders’ agreement that fits the company’s actual situation. Contact the head office at 49 First Avenue, Linden, Randburg, 011 888 0246 (after-hours 061 516 6878), or visit the branch closest to you across the firm’s Gauteng network.

General Information Disclaimer: This article is general information about shareholders’ agreements in South African private companies and the Companies Act 71 of 2008. It is not legal advice for a specific situation, the right agreement depends on the company, its shareholders, and its plans. Consult a qualified attorney before signing or amending one. For the current statutory text, confirm against the Companies and Intellectual Property Commission and the official gazetted Act.

CONTACT US

 

This is a demonstration. The contact form is not connected.

NEED TOP LEGAL SUPPORT IN SOUTH AFRICA? CONTACT OUR LAWYERS TODAY.

Contact our team of experienced law attorneys at Burger Huyser Attorneys to assist you in all matters and procedures.

CONTACT DETAILS

CONTACT US TODAY

  • RANDBURG OFFICE

    011 888 0246 / 061 516 6878

    After Hours Bail Application
    069 522 7696

  • ROODEPOORT OFFICE

    011 668 0030 / 061 516 0091

    After Hours Bail Application
    061 516 0091

  • SANDTON OFFICE

    011 253 3080 / 064 555 3358

    After Hours Bail Application
    064 555 3358

  • PRETORIA OFFICE

    012 471 5700 / 064 548 4838

    After Hours Bail Application
    064 548 4838

  • BEDFORDVIEW OFFICE

    011 201 7190 / 061 536 3223

    After Hours Bail Application
    061 536 3223

  • CENTURION OFFICE

    012 644 4990 / 061 516 7117

    After Hours Bail Application
    069 522 7696

  • ALBERTON OFFICE

    011 439 3990 / 061 515 4699

    After Hours Bail Application
    061 515 4699

  • MIDRAND OFFICE

    010 022 4082 / 064 555 3358

    After Hours Bail Application
    077 274 1932

  • DEBT COLLECTION OFFICE

    011 446 5960 / 079 109 8470

    Monday - Friday; 7:30 AM - 16:30 PM

Speak to Burger Huyser Attorneys

Bedfordview office: 011 201 7190, Monday to Friday, 7:30 AM – 4:30 PM

Request a consultation
Demonstration build by Ozone Development. Not affiliated with or commissioned by this business.